Rated | Alphabetical
| Highest Rated 2006
Radiohead: I Might Be Wrong: Live Recordings
When it comes to its music, Radiohead isn't afraid of a little mutation. On
Kid A and Amnesiac, the band's songs seemed to have been carefully
sculpted and then chaotically deconstructed. With I Might Be Wrong the
group brings its unique brand of sonic alchemy to a live setting.
Normally, bands that rely on studio trickery/wizardry for amplified effect
fall embarrassingly short when attempting to reproduce those sounds before
paying customers. After all, acoustics change with each venue, and no two
performances are ever the same. Radiohead trumps this near-inalterable axiom by
treating its music as a liquid, rather than a solid, something eager for
reinvention, effortlessly reborn in new formats. As experienced live, the band
recasts its blender-spun recent tracks into the musical equivalent of mercury:
volatile, unsteady, but completely malleable and, when poured through the right
mold, quite potent.
Throughout, Thom Yorke and company appear comfortable exploring the more
divergent aspects of these songs, even at the expense of confounding the
expectations of fans. A prime example is the reinvention of Amnesiac's "Like
Spinning Plates," which is transformed from its backward-looped, chopped vocal
studio version into a pained, affecting, piano ballad, with chief lyricist Yorke
singing: "While you make pretty speeches/I'm being cut to shreds/You feed me to
the lions/A delicate balance/And this just feels like spinning plates."
One of the more pleasant and startling revelations throughout the record is
the emergence of drummer Phil Selway from behind the wall of sound normally
heard on Radiohead's polished studio works. The propulsive beat on "I Might Be
Wrong" is simply fantastic, driving the song forward, yet never overwhelming it.
On "Morning Bell" Selway brings a mad, skittering urgency to the song that's
missing from either the Kid A or Amnesiac versions.
The main problem with I Might Be Wrong is actually a backhanded
compliment: It's simply too short, offering eight tracks that cover just over 40
minutes. This being Radiohead's first official live release, one would have
hoped for something that more closely approaches the feeling of a full concert,
if possible taken from one show rather than the three European dates captured
here. It's basically a best-of live collection that, while a nice souvenir for
diehards, ultimately leaves the listener -- especially one who hasn't enjoyed the
benefit of seeing the band in concert -- wanting for more. Hopefully, the group
will address this issue in the not too distant future. For now, this engaging,
yet short-lived experiment will simply have to do.
design copyright © 2001-2011 Shaking Through.net. All original artwork,
photography and text used on this site is the sole copyright of the respective creator(s)/author(s). Reprinting, reposting, or citing any of the original
content appearing on this site without the written consent of Shaking
Through.net is strictly forbidden.